The Inspiration Trap: Why More Ideas Aren't Always Better for Your Creativity

More inspiration, more tutorials, more ideas, more possibilities... but is all that inspiration actually helping your creativity?

When I went to art school, it was before we all had mobile phones, and before social media existed (yes, really!).

It actually feels very weird to write that down, because it's so hard to imagine life without them now.

Pretty much anything you can think of is available at the tap, tap, tap of a few buttons.

And whilst having access to all that information offers us immense freedom and opportunity, I actually think it's made something else much harder: figuring out who we are, what we stand for, and what inspires us creatively.

When we can quite literally find everything under the sun in a tiny metal box we can neatly slip into our pocket, it's very easy to start looking OUTSIDE ourselves for the answers.

And I think most of us (and I count myself here too!) have become rather accustomed to believing that the answer is MORE.

More inspiration.
More art materials.
More tutorials.
More ideas.
More other artists to know, learn about and copy.
More possibilities.

Just MORE.

A Minion enthusiastically stuffing its mouth – a humorous illustration of the temptation to consume more and more ideas.

And specifically, when we hit a tricky spell with our art, get stuck or aren't sure what to do next, rather than sitting with that discomfort and figuring things out for ourselves, we automatically assume there must be an answer hidden somewhere in all that MORE.

If only we could find The Answer: that ONE thing that would magically make everything click into place.

When inspiration becomes a distraction

But the problem is, the more we look outside ourselves for creative direction, the harder it can become to tune into what's actually happening inside.

What do we genuinely like and dislike? What are we curious about exploring? What do we want our art to say?

And something else happens too.

We start comparing our work to everyone else's. We become distracted by all the different shiny things we COULD be making.

We spend so much time gathering and consuming inspiration that we don't leave ourselves much space to actually explore it.

And perhaps most importantly, we can lose sight of the things that genuinely interest US.

How can you hear your own creative voice above all that noise anyway?!

So, should we stop looking for inspiration?

Well, I don't think it's necessarily about abandoning social media or never looking at another tutorial again!

In an ideal world, we might all take a little holiday from the noise, but it's not always possible, practical or even preferable. Social media isn't the enemy after all!

But perhaps the relationship between social media and our creativity is something we need to get a bit more intentional about, so that we can make a little more space for our OWN inspiration.

A creative prompt encouraging you to look for inspiration beyond social media and online tutorials.

Here are three things you could try.

1. Take a little holiday from consuming

If you can, try taking a break from scrolling, watching tutorials, browsing art supplies and looking for new ideas.

If that's not practical, just try reducing the amount you're consuming.

I know this can be hard! Here are a few things you might find helpful:

  • Delete certain apps from your phone, accessing them only on your computer.

  • Use apps or devices that can help you limit access to certain apps, or restrict them at particular times of day.

  • If you find this super tricky, start by just doing it one day per week, then build up from there.

You might be surprised by what happens when you stop filling every spare moment with other people's ideas and give yourself a little breathing room.

Sometimes, having fewer ideas coming in is exactly what you need to start discovering your own.

2. Get yourself out and about

It could be as simple as a walk around the block, or it could be somewhere a lot more exciting.

Going somewhere new can really change your energy when you're feeling stuck, and give you a completely different perspective.

You don't need to go somewhere particularly inspiring or beautiful. Sometimes the most interesting things are hiding in the most ordinary places!

I have found soooo many little nuggets of inspiration from the short walk doing the school run - it just takes shifting your perspective and being open to seeing things differently sometimes.

A collection of everyday visual details and textures spotted on a walk, offering inspiration for creative projects.

Some little nuggets of inspiration that have caught my eye recently

Notice the shapes of buildings, the colours of shop fronts, the patterns on pavements, the way light falls across a wall, or the little details you might usually walk straight past.

You never know what might catch your eye.

If you're looking for more ways to get your creative juices flowing, take a look at my free Jump Start Your Art guide, packed with 25 playful exercises to help you get making.

3. Start noticing what YOU are drawn to

This is probably the most important of the three.

Pay attention to the things in the real world that catch your eye.

It might be the colours you keep walking towards when you're clothes shopping, the books you pick up in a bookshop, the plants you notice on your walk to work, the colour of a car that makes you stop and look, or a poster in a shop window whose design you absolutely LOVE.

And here's a little experiment I'd love you to try.

A 24-hour inspiration experiment

Over the next 24 hours, make a point of noticing these little things.

Don't go looking for anything in particular. Just pay attention.

At the end of the day, jot down three things that caught your attention and ask yourself:

What is it about these things that I find so interesting?

Is it the colours? The shapes? The patterns? The textures? Something else entirely?

You don't need to make anything with them, or even collect them.

Just start noticing what naturally draws you in.

Because this is where things start to get interesting!

When you begin to recognise the things you're naturally attracted to, you start building a much clearer picture of your own creative preferences.

And those preferences are an important part of developing your creative voice.

For example, I’m not really surprised by the things I was drawn to in the photos above - because I know that I’m incredibly inspired by colour and pattern, and both of those things are key ingredients of my creative voice.

Finding your own creative voice

This is actually one of the things we explore inside my signature programme, Nurture, and I know it's one of the parts of the programme that has the biggest impact on my students and their art practice.

Because when you start understanding your own preferences, you have a much clearer sense of direction, and of who you are creatively.

Rather than constantly searching for inspiration or relying on other people's ideas, you begin to develop the confidence to make creative decisions for yourself.

And your art starts to feel so much more like YOU, rather than a random collection of other people's ideas stitched together inside a YouTube playlist!

That's not to say you should never learn from other artists, follow tutorials or experiment with different techniques. Of course you should!

But there's a big difference between using other people's work as a starting point for exploration and feeling like you need someone else's ideas to tell you what to make.

The more you understand what interests you, the more confidently you can take inspiration from the world around you and make it your own.

And that's where the really interesting stuff happens.

You don't need more inspiration. You need a little more space to discover what already inspires you.

Want to explore this further?

If you'd love to move beyond tutorials and discover the art that only YOU can make, I'd love to introduce you to Nurture.

Nurture is my immersive 3-month signature programme, where we explore the foundations of a meaningful creative practice, helping you reconnect with your creative voice, build confidence in your own ideas and develop an art practice that feels much more like you.

We don't just jump straight into techniques and making more art. We start by exploring your values, purpose and inspiration, so you can build a much clearer sense of direction before deciding where you want your creativity to take you.

If that sounds like something you'd be interested in, you can find out more and join the waitlist here:

JOIN THE NURTURE WAITLIST

And whether you're interested in Nurture or not, I hope these ideas have given you a little something to think about.

Happy creating!

Mel xx

"Be yourself. Everyone else is already taken."

This quote is often attributed to Oscar Wilde, although there's no reliable evidence he actually said it. Its original author remains unknown!

Next
Next

MINDFUL DRAWING TUTORIAL: GROW